The seat of government for the Coeur d'Alene Tribe, at the west end of a 73-mile paved trail.
US-95 meets State Highway 5 here. Marimn Health and the Tribe are the employers. Prices and incomes run well under Kootenai County, sales volume is thin, and the fee-versus-trust land question is real. Jeremy sells here and will tell you which one a parcel is before you write an offer.
Plummer sits in western Benewah County where US-95 crosses State Highway 5, at 2,722 feet. The 2020 census counted 1,015 people inside 1.25 square miles — down from 1,044 in 2010. The Census Bureau classifies 100% of the city as rural. It is the largest city entirely within the Coeur d'Alene Reservation, and it is where the Coeur d'Alene Tribe's government sits. Coeur d'Alene is 35 miles north. St. Maries is 18 miles east on SH-5. Moscow is 50 miles south. The Washington line is 9 miles west.
The railroad came first. The Oregon Washington Railway & Navigation Company built a line through here in 1890, and the Milwaukee Road added an adjacent line in 1909 — the crossing became Plummer Junction. The townsite was platted in 1909 and the city incorporated in 1910. The name is not the outlaw Henry Plummer, despite what people around here will tell you; it came from Elva Leo Plummer, a surveyor on the townsite crew whose camp was called Plummer's Camp. Federal legislation in 1906 opened the reservation to non-tribal settlement, and on August 9, 1909 roughly 1,500 parcels were distributed among more than 100,000 applicants. Tribal heads of household received 160-acre allotments; the surplus went to homesteaders who had to clear the ponderosa pine to prove up. That single event is why land ownership in and around Plummer is a checkerboard today, and why the question below matters.
What's here now: the Tribe's government, the Bureau of Indian Affairs Coeur d'Alene Agency at 925 A Street, and Marimn Health — the Tribe's medical center on N 12th Street and wellness center on A Street, which together serve tribal members and the surrounding community. The Coeur d'Alene Casino Resort Hotel and Circling Raven Golf Club are about ten miles north on US-95 in Worley. The western terminus of the 73.2-mile Trail of the Coeur d'Alenes is in town, and Heyburn State Park starts a few miles east. The honest part: 35 miles is a real drive. Full-service retail, the regional hospital corridor and the airport are all in Kootenai County. Median household income in Plummer runs $54,306 against $81,861 in Kootenai County, and the median property value is $197,200 against $518,700. That gap is the reason people buy here and the reason the market behaves the way it does.
83851 covers the city plus a large rural area of farm ground, timber and lake country reaching east toward Chatcolet. The city is 1.25 square miles; the ZIP is far bigger, which is why ZIP-level price data reads much higher than in-town sales.
Worley (10 miles north on US-95), St. Maries (18 miles east on SH-5), Tensed and DeSmet (south on US-95), Harrison (northeast along the lake), Coeur d'Alene (35 miles north).
Plummer is thin enough that one closing sets the median. Every figure below is labeled by geography — city of Plummer, ZIP 83851, Benewah County or Kootenai County — so you can see exactly what you're reading. Sources: Redfin, three months ending June 2026, and American Community Survey 2024 estimates.
Plummer sits inside the Coeur d'Alene Reservation, and land inside reservation boundaries comes in more than one legal form. Fee simple land is ordinary real estate: the owner holds full legal title, it can be sold without federal approval, and it can carry a conventional mortgage. Trust land is different — the federal government holds legal title in trust for the Tribe or an individual tribal owner, the land cannot be conveyed without federal consent, and financing runs through a BIA-approved lease pledged as security rather than a mortgage on the land itself. Restricted fee land sits in between: the owner holds title but cannot sell without BIA approval. Fee land inside reservation boundaries also remains subject to tribal jurisdiction. None of this is a problem. It is a fact you confirm parcel by parcel, in writing, before you write an offer.
Plummer is the seat of government for the Coeur d'Alene Tribe, and the Tribe's operations are the job base. Marimn Health — the medical center at 427 N 12th Street and the wellness center at 1100 A Street — began in 1990 as Benewah Medical Center, the first partnership between the Indian Health Service and Health and Human Services to create a tribally run community health center. It was renamed Marimn Health in 2017, from the Coeur d'Alene word marim, "to treat." The Tribe employs roughly 1,000 people across government, agriculture and gaming, farms about 6,000 acres, and runs a lumber mill, an automotive center, a hardware store and food markets. The Coeur d'Alene Casino Resort Hotel and Circling Raven Golf Club are ten miles north in Worley. In a town of 1,015, that concentration is the whole picture.
The Trail of the Coeur d'Alenes runs 73.2 paved miles from Plummer east to Mullan, and the western trailhead is here. It was built on the Union Pacific right-of-way — a line laid around 1888 to serve the Silver Valley mines and abandoned in 1991 — and the asphalt surface plus gravel shoulders function as an engineered cap over a railbed contaminated by mine tailings. The Tribe manages roughly 15 miles of it inside the reservation. Heyburn State Park, 8,076 acres and the oldest state park in the Pacific Northwest, sits a few miles east on SH-5 with Chatcolet and Benewah lakes. Buyers who ride, paddle or fish know this corner. Most listings here never mention it.
One closed sale inside city limits in the three months ending June 2026, at a $334,000 median. ZIP 83851 recorded eight sales at a $509,000 median over the same window. Same postal code, two different markets, and every search portal blends them under the word "Plummer." An appraiser cannot build a grid from one sale, so comparables get pulled from Worley, Tensed, St. Maries and the Heyburn side, then adjusted for acreage, water source, outbuildings and land status. Those adjustments are judgment calls. If nobody hands the appraiser a documented file, someone else's assumptions set your price.
A small town with a tribal government, a health system, a state park next door and 73 miles of pavement starting at the edge of town. Also 35 miles from a Costco. Both halves are true.
73.2 paved miles from Plummer to Mullan, climbing and dropping between about 2,200 and 3,400 feet. It follows the old Union Pacific line built around 1888 for the Silver Valley mines and abandoned in 1991. Because the railbed carried mine waste, the asphalt and the gravel shoulders are a permanent engineered cap — you stay on the surface, and that rule is posted for a reason. The Coeur d'Alene Tribe manages roughly 15 miles of it. East of town the trail crosses the south end of Lake Coeur d'Alene on the Chatcolet Bridge, a trestle built around a 1921 swing-span truss. Living at the trailhead means you ride on a Tuesday evening without loading a bike rack.
8,076 acres a few miles east on SH-5, created in 1908 — the oldest state park in the Pacific Northwest. Chatcolet and Benewah lakes sit at the south end of Lake Coeur d'Alene, where the Coeur d'Alene River comes in. Hawley's Landing and Benewah campgrounds hold 72 standard sites, 57 serviced sites, two cabins and two cottages. Much of the original construction was Civilian Conservation Corps work between 1934 and 1941. Equestrian loops — Scout Out, Gandy Dancer, Rocky Top, Ponderosa Ridge — plus the hiking-only Cedar Loop and the paved trail running straight through it.
The honest inventory. Marimn Health runs a medical center at 427 N 12th Street with medical, dental, behavioral health, optometry, chiropractic, radiology, lab, pharmacy and physical therapy, plus a wellness center at 1100 A Street with a gym and aquatics complex and the Boys & Girls Club of the Coeur d'Alene Tribe. The Tribe's government offices are here. So is the BIA's Coeur d'Alene Agency at 925 A Street. Lakeside Elementary, Lakeside Jr High and Lakeside High are all in town. City water, and a small business core. No big-box retail. Full grocery and hardware runs go north toward Coeur d'Alene or east to St. Maries. Mean commute time in Plummer is 18.7 minutes, which tells you most people who live here work here.
Ten miles north on US-95 in Worley, the Coeur d'Alene Casino Resort Hotel opened in 1993 as a $2.7 million bingo hall and now runs a 100,000-square-foot gaming floor, two hotel towers and Circling Raven Golf Club. It is one of the largest employers in the region and the closest thing to a night out without driving to Coeur d'Alene. Past that, US-95 keeps going: Coeur d'Alene at 35 miles, Spokane and the airport past it. Going the other way, SH-5 runs 19 miles east to St. Maries through Heyburn. That's the map. Decide now whether those distances work for your life, because they do not change.
One district, three schools, 333 students, all of it in town. The ratings are low and the two national systems disagree with each other. Here are both, unedited.
Three things a buying family should know plainly. First, everything is in town — elementary, junior high and high school are all on E Street in Plummer, so there is no long secondary bus route the way there is in a lot of small North Idaho districts. Second, the ratings are low and they contradict each other. GreatSchools gives Lakeside High School a 1 out of 10 while Niche gives the same school a C+, with sub-grades of B+ for teachers, B for college prep and A− for resources and facilities. GreatSchools leans hard on state test proficiency; Niche blends in surveys and other inputs. The district graduation rate is 55% and 70% of Lakeside High students receive free or reduced lunch. GreatSchools also flags 2024 attendance at Lakeside High at 41% against an Idaho average of 85%. Those numbers are real and we are not going to bury them. Third, the published grade configurations from the national sites list the elementary as PK/K–5 and the junior high as 7–8, which leaves grade 6 unaccounted for — confirm the current configuration and attendance boundaries with the district office directly before you buy. North Idaho College's main campus is in Coeur d'Alene, 35 miles north; the University of Idaho is in Moscow, 50 miles south.
The calendar here is largely the Tribe's calendar, and a lot of it happens either in town or ten miles north at the casino. One note on Julyamsh: the Tribe's powwow has moved venues more than once — Post Falls Greyhound Park, then the Kootenai County Fairgrounds — and no confirmed current dates or location were published at the time this page was written. Confirm with the Tribe before you plan around it.
March 21, 2026 · The 33rd Anniversary Powwow at the Coeur d'Alene Casino Resort Hotel Event Center, 37914 S Nukwalqw in Worley. Grand entries at 1pm and 7pm. Everyone welcome. cdacasino.com
Late July · Held at the Wellness Center on A Street in Plummer, 10am to 3pm. Run by the Tribe. The kind of event that tells you what a town of 1,015 actually feels like on a Saturday.
August · Culture Camp runs an all-day session out at the lake; Rhythm on the Rez is held at the Coeur Center. Both are Coeur d'Alene Tribe programs. councilfires.com
Mid-August · Three days at Circling Raven Golf Club at the Coeur d'Alene Casino in Worley. The course is the reason a fair number of out-of-area visitors ever come down US-95 past Coeur d'Alene.
Late October · The Tribe's annual sqigwts harvest at Hawley's Landing in Heyburn State Park, on the south end of Lake Coeur d'Alene. Tribal members, school groups and the general public dig water potatoes together, with booths on language, ecology and traditional foods.
November through March · The trail empties, Heyburn goes still, and US-95 is just a highway again. This is the half of the year visitors never see and the half that decides whether someone actually wants to live in Plummer. Come look at the town in February before you commit.
One home closed inside the city of Plummer in the three months ending June 2026. One. Over the same window ZIP 83851 recorded eight sales at a $509,000 median while the city median sat at $334,000. There is no usable local comp set, which means the number on your home gets built from sales in Worley, Tensed, St. Maries and the Heyburn side, adjusted by someone who may never have stood on your property. If you don't assemble that comp file and hand it over, their assumptions become your price.
The second thing that has to be handled here and nowhere else in North Idaho is land status. A buyer's lender is going to ask whether the parcel is fee simple, trust, or restricted fee, because the answer changes the loan. Fee simple takes a conventional mortgage. Trust land is held in title by the federal government for the Tribe or an individual owner, cannot be conveyed without federal consent, and is financed through a BIA-approved lease rather than a mortgage on the land. Restricted fee needs BIA approval to convey. Get the county record and the land-status documentation in the file before the listing goes live, not after a lender kills a contract in week three. Then price it honestly: median household income here is $54,306 against $81,861 in Kootenai County, and a Coeur d'Alene comp does not translate.
An automated valuation cannot price a home in Plummer. It has one city sale to work from, it blends the city with a much larger ZIP, and it has no idea whether your parcel is fee or trust. Jeremy will drive down, look at the property, pull the comps an appraiser will actually reach for, confirm the land status, and give you a real number with the reasoning attached.
The full 48-Point Marketing Guarantee. Media Company Shoot Day, Immersive 360 tour, 20-Post Content Battery, Relocation Buyer Funnel into WA/CA/OR zip codes, Thursday Launch, Weekly Property Reports, Cancel Anytime. This is how Plummer resale homes compete against builder model units on the same block.
Learn More →For buyers who want to actually land in Plummer without competing on Zillow against 139 active listings. Off-market access through the eXp network before properties go public — plus a strategy built around your RV garage needs, school district priorities, acreage requirements, and commute tolerance.
Learn More →Not every Plummer seller wants a full marketing campaign. Sometimes the priority is speed, certainty, and no showings. The Instant Cash Offer gives you a real number — no obligation — so you can compare it against going to market and decide on your terms, not anyone else's timeline.
Learn More →Did your Plummer listing expire? The LEX audit scores the actual marketing campaign that ran on your property — platform distribution, photo quality, video presence, social cadence, pricing strategy against builder comps. Scored out of 100. Most expired Plummer listings score below 40 before we even get to pricing.
Run the Audit →The city median says $334,000 off a single closing. The ZIP median says $509,000 off eight. Here's how to tell which one describes your house before an appraiser decides for you.
Read more →Land inside the Coeur d'Alene Reservation comes in more than one legal form, and the form changes how it is bought, sold and financed. What the difference is, and exactly who to ask.
Read more →Median property value here is $197,200 against $518,700 in Kootenai County. That discount is real. So is the drive. Here's the honest accounting on both.
Read more →More Plummer market updates, land-status guides and seller strategy added regularly.
Visit SoldBySpecials.com
Jeremy works Kootenai County from waterfront CDA to prairie Plummer — and the Plummer market is one he tracks closely. New construction comps, builder incentive strategies, RV garage floor plan values, Lakeland district boundaries, which subdivisions are selling out and which are sitting — this is the day-to-day knowledge that separates a listing that moves in a tight market from one that sits while sellers wonder why.
For sellers, that means a campaign that actually competes with what builders are offering on the next block. For buyers, it means a search strategy built around what you actually need — not just whatever's active on Zillow this week.
208-770-9645 · jeremy@soldbyspecials.com · eXp Realty · Idaho Licensed
Selling into a competitive market, searching for your first North Idaho home, or figuring out what your expired listing needs — pick your path below.
Jeremy will personally review your property and reach out within 24 hours with your free Home Value Consultation.
Book a Call Now →Jeremy will reach out within 24 hours to build your personalized Exclusive Home Hunter™ strategy for Plummer.
Book a Call Now →We'll deliver your no-obligation cash offer within 24 hours. All information stays completely private.
Book a Call Instead →Jeremy will personally review your expired listing and deliver your free Listing Exposure X-Ray™ within 24 hours.
Book a Call Now →